Re: [Tails-dev] Please review and merge feature/remember_ins…

Nachricht löschen

Nachricht beantworten
Autor: sajolida
Datum:  
To: The Tails public development discussion list
Betreff: Re: [Tails-dev] Please review and merge feature/remember_installed_packages
> Thanks for your review!
>
>> I tested it and corrected a small bug in the code that prevented
>> installing two or more packages. See 75bb8cc4.
>>
> Nice catch. I introduced this bug while trying to fix another one:
> installing the package "[]" when live-additional-software.conf is
> present but empty. You fix reintroduces this bug, an I'm afraid it also
> adds another one (not displaying the list of packages that will
> actually be installed if the conffile is modified while installing). I
> think f79c70a addresses both issues.


Sorry for not fixing the issue entirely. Now the logic seems all right,
but I didn't test.

>> Apart from that I did a bunch of languages fixes, both in the code and
>> the documentation. Tell me what you think.
>>
> Seems me alright but:
>
> "They are automatically upgraded for security and installed after a
> network connection is established." which seems me unclear (the new
> version is installed for security too; the upgrade happense when
> network connectivity appears too; and upgrading means installing a
> new version, no? I propose "They are automatically upgraded for security
> after a network connection is established." (fb4f909)


Much better, thank you.

>> Then I have a doubt for which I didn't find a clear solution yet:
>>
>> config/chroot_local-includes/usr/local/sbin/tails-additional-software:84
>> "You can find more information in the system log."
>>
>> I don't find this phrase useful. If I'm a user: where can I find this
>> "system log"? Can I just try something to solve the problem instead?
>> "Check your network connection or restart Tails", maybe? Propose to
>> report a bug?
>>
> I replaced it by "The upgrade failed. This might be due to a network
> problem. You may want to check your network connexion of restart Tails.
> It the problem persist, please report a bug." (3a7697e). What do you
> think?


That's better as well. Commit 1a54a42 shortens it a bit.