Autor: anonym Datum: To: The Tails public development discussion list Betreff: Re: [Tails-dev] Please review and merge feature/live-boot-3.x
12/12/12 15:16, anonym wrote: > 12/12/12 15:01, intrigeri wrote:
>> anonym wrote (12 Dec 2012 13:22:49 GMT) :
>>>> I am unlikely to have time to test it before the freeze,
>>>> so "please review and merge" again if you feel like testing it first.
>>>>
>>>> Else, I guess this will mature for 0.17.
>>
>>> I think the latter is the best.
>>
>> OK. Thanks for thinking of it!
>>
>>> It's not like we're missing out on some highly necessary
>>> features/bugfixes by not doing this, so I don't think it's worth
>>> the risk.
>>
>> I probably have not made it clear enough, but my main motivation for
>> pushing this branch in time for 0.16 was Debian bug #688782.
>> Quoting Gaudenz:
>>
>> I'm setting the severity to grave as without these changes the
>> persistence filesystems can not be seen from the live system and
>> therefore cannot be remounted readonly on shutdown. This leaves
>> these filesystem in an inconsistent state which may lead to data
>> corruption.
>>
>> ... but still, I'm unsure this would be worth the risks,
>> and I absolutely don't mean to be insisting.
>
> The way I understand it, those patches are only relevant if persistence
> is activated in initramfs time. Since we activate it in user space, the
> mounts are done on a visible part of the filesystem, so we're safe.
Actually, the relevant patch,
0003-Move-mountpoints-below-live-persistence-rofs.patch, modifies code
in live-boot that our live-persist script will never touch. We're
definitely safe.
